|Team:||Football, Track and Field; Inducted 2016|
2x HM All-American as a wide receiver, 4x Academic All-American, 7x Track and Field All-American.
In his career, Theisen has 41 games, 218 catches, 3,223 yards, and 25 touchdowns. He graduated as the St. Thomas school-record holder in receptions and receiving yards. (They have since been broken.)
In track and field, Theisen still holds three school records (400 hurdles outdoor, 55 hurdles indoor, 4x400 relay indoor). Twice place third in NCAA outdoor in 400 hurdles, twice he ran on indoor NCAA runner-up 4x400 relays.